Homebuyers Are Adjusting to Higher Rates—Here’s How You Can Still Land Your Dream Home on the Treasure Coast

August 05, 2025•5 min read

Buying a home on the Treasure Coast in 2025 looks a little different than the "hot market" years we're coming out of. Mortgage rates are higher, but there's more inventory than we've seen in a while, and smart buyers are using some new tricks to turn these challenges into opportunities. If you’re hoping to settle down in Martin, St. Lucie, or Indian River County, you’re in a great spot—as long as you know how to play the game.

Here’s our honest, friendly scoop on how you can still land your dream home, even as rates stay higher than you’d like.

1. The New Market Reality: More Choices, More Leverage

If you’ve been hunting for a home over the past couple of years, you know just how tight the market has been. Bidding wars, frantic timelines, and hardly any room to negotiate. The good news? Things have calmed down.

Inventory is up: In Martin County, active listings leapt from about 590 in early 2023 to 829 at the end of 2024. That means more homes to pick from, not just leftover listings and fixer-uppers.

Why it matters:

You can be choosy: Compare several properties, not just one or two that meet your criteria.
Negotiating is back: With more competition among sellers, you might find closing cost help or even a price cut.
Time is on your side: Less “panic buying.” Take enough time to inspect, research, and think things through.

2. Tackling Higher Rates With Smart Financing

We won’t sugarcoat: Mortgage rates have risen and may stay there for a while. But that doesn’t mean your dream home’s out of reach. Here’s how buyers are responding:

A. Lock Now, Refinance Later

Many buyers are using a “buy now, refi later” strategy.

B. Explore Your Loan Options

Not all mortgages look the same. Talk with a local broker (like us!) about:

C. Seller Concessions Are Back

With rising inventory, sellers are often more open to help buyers with:

3. Get More for Your Money: New Construction & Feature-Packed Homes

Another trend on the Treasure Coast is the boost in new home construction, especially in communities like Port St. Lucie’s Tradition or Legacy Park.

Why you’ll love new construction:

Energy efficiency: Lower monthly bills for things like utilities and insurance; new builds are often up to the latest codes for storms and wind.
Customization: Choose finishes, layouts, and add-ons before you move in.
Lower maintenance: Everything’s fresh and under warranty.
Check out local options for new builds here.

4. Insurance, Storms, and Picking the Right Spot

It wouldn’t be Florida without talking insurance! It’s a must-buy, but on the Treasure Coast the cost can be a factor—especially for coastal properties.

How to keep things affordable:

Inland or higher-ground homesoften come with lower premiums than waterfront or barrier island properties.
Storm-resistant features: Metal roofs, hurricane windows, reinforced doors, and properly engineered garages can all bring costs down (sometimes alot).
Compare, compare, compare: Don't just look at the home price—get quotes for insurance before you make your offer. Ask for seller’s insurance declarations to see past premiums.

Bonus tip:Negotiate with sellers to provide recent wind mitigation and 4-point inspection reports. These can help you qualify for better insurance rates or make informed requests before closing.

5. Budget Like a Pro: The Real Numbers

Even if you have your heart set on the beach, don’t forget the “hidden costs” in your monthly payment—taxes, insurance, association or condo fees, and maintenance. The Treasure Coast remains one of the most affordable spots in South Florida, but you still need to budget carefully, especially in a changing market.

Your best bet? Work with local pros (like us or a trusted agent) to crunch the numbers before you make an offer.

6. Use Local Experts—We’re Here to Help!

The Treasure Coast isn’t just any Florida market. Regulations, insurance quirks, storm rules, and lending products are constantly evolving.

Why you need an expert:

7. Making Your Dream a Reality (Even Now)

Yes, rates are higher—but that doesn’t mean you should press pause on your dream. Inventory is rising and prices are more reasonable. With smart planning, the right partners, and a willingness to think a little “outside the box,” you can absolutely find (and afford) a home that’s just right for you and your family.

If you have questions about your specific scenario, feel free to schedule a chat with us at Treasure Coast Mortgage—we love helping buyers crush their goals (even in a tricky market).

Want to learn more or see what loan programs you qualify for? Visit tcmortgage.comor reach out anytime—we’re real people who actually live here, and we’re happy to help you navigate your route home.

Emmett Dempsey

Emmett Dempsey is a licensed mortgage broker, U.S. Army veteran, and the founder of Treasure Coast Mortgage, LLC in Port St. Lucie, Florida. With over 15 years in the mortgage industry, Emmett specializes in VA loans, Non-QM financing, and reverse mortgages — with a particular passion for helping fellow veterans and first-time buyers succeed in today’s market. Known for his clear, honest advice and deep local knowledge, Emmett’s mission is simple: make mortgages make sense. Whether you’re buying your first home, refinancing, or exploring creative loan options, Emmett brings the expertise and options you need to close with confidence. When he’s not working deals or coaching clients, you’ll find him coaching youth football, cheering on his kids at dance competitions, or building content to educate Florida homebuyers.

Back to Blog